Survivors of Extreme Abuse: The Awful Rowing Toward Social Emancipation

For survivors of extreme abuse, the disclosure of the crimes they experienced and the public identification of the perpetrators of those crimes can be monumentally daunting tasks. Among the impediments they may face in their pursuit of personal and social justice are their own psychological challenges, due to the complex, and sometimes debilitating effects of having experienced severe trauma, the dangers inherent in exposing criminals or criminal networks, and social denial of their plight on almost every level.

“A woman’s first scream is for help. Her second scream is for justice.”

– Coral Anika Theill, BONSHEA

IMAGINE

Survivors have an invaluable gift to share with society: intimate knowledge of crimes perpetrated in their midst, and the criminals who committed them. Their knowledge and insight could theoretically lift the great rock of our cultural denial and officially sanctioned version of reality, and expose the dark and dangerous world of child, drug and arms traffickers, rapists, child pornographers, serial killers, cults, secret societies and government corruption. And that exposure would surely mark the beginning of the end of the widespread abuses that plague our society now.

But that doesn’t happen.

SPEAK NO EVIL

Survivors need to tell their stories; it’s a vital component of their healing process. And they need to be heard; it’s a vital component of society’s healing process. But for many survivors, establishing the requisite trust in a personal or therapeutic relationship for this to happen can be a big challenge in and of itself. To speak that truth publicly can be an overwhelmingly complex and terrifying undertaking. They risk being stigmatized, disbelieved, harassed, sued or physically harmed.

When a survivor reports criminal abuses to law enforcement agencies, she or he can expect to be met with breathtaking ignorance on the subjects of the prevalence of rape and incest, the sheer numbers of children who live under the social radar,[i] (either completely undocumented, as in the case of children of cult members and the like, or under the control of abusers who keep them isolated) and a limited understanding of post traumatic stress syndromes, if any. The requisite legal infrastructure for dealing with extreme abuse is next to non-existent.

For example, with the notable exception of Michigan,[ii] US victims of non-state actor torture are not specifically protected by law. This is because the crime has not been officially named and recognized legislatively. In 2008, Jeanne Sarson, MEd, BN, RN, and Linda MacDonald, MEd, BN, RN, two renowned survivor advocates in Nova Scotia, wrote a report called Torture of Canadian Women by Non-State Actors In the Private Sphere[iii] in their effort to make all of Canada a “torture-free zone.”  In this report they explain why officially recognizing non-state actor torture is so crucial:

“…Canada’s failure to name and criminalize non-state actor torture means, for example, that the women are not believed when they seek police protection, thus their safety is compromised. They cannot lay criminal charges identifying that they have endured torture in the private sphere because no specific law criminalizing non-state actor torture exists in Canada. And when there is no specific law there is no such recognized crime. The women frequently experience discreditation, are considered ‘crazy’, or are labeled mentally ill when seeking professional help.”

Some victims risk more than being shunned and stigmatized when they disclose abuses to authorities. In cases of cult, cult/government and other organized crimes, the survivor runs the risk of reporting the crime to a person who is part of the crime network, whether it be a police officer, attorney, judge, federal agent or politician.[iv] Compounding these conundrums is the fact that many survivors tend to isolate, and often distrust organizations and institutions in general. All of this, of course, works in favor of the perpetrators.

In addition to the obvious risks involved in publicly naming names, survivors often have to cope with memories of having been specifically threatened with violence in the past if they dared to expose their perpetrators.

Complicating this task even further, some survivors of extreme abuse have been programmed to “switch” to alters who will behave in such a way as to destroy their own credibility, or even to commit suicide if they start talking about their abuse. Results from the first ever international survey of survivors of extreme abuse[v] include statistics regarding the prevalence of this and other silencing techniques: 57% of 997 respondents said they had self-destruct programming installed should they begin to remember their programming, and 77% of 1159 respondents were threatened with death if they so much as talked about the abuse.

Another common practice among handlers and programmers is to install alters who have been programmed to report any potentially damaging disclosure of their abuse to the perpetrators of that abuse. In other words, internally covert tattletales.

Survivors are also at a great disadvantage in more subtle and insidious ways. When it comes to exposing perpetrators and their crimes, many survivors experience deeply conflicted needs and drives, obstacles such as learned helplessness, self-blame and other disempowering beliefs and attitudes.

HEAR NO EVIL

Socially the constraints on disclosure are also confounding, if not prohibitive. One deterrent is the simple fact that well-qualified health care professionals are usually very expensive. This alone represents a major obstacle for many survivors. Finding a qualified therapist is also a big challenge. It’s still a rare therapist who has a clear understanding of cult psychodynamics, or who’s been trained to treat the full range of what can be very complex post-traumatic experience.

Part of the problem is that this field of study as a psychiatric science is relatively new. The diagnosis of PTSD[vi] (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder) only made the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM, in 1980. There are mental health professionals who still believe that survivors who disclose histories of extreme abuse are acting out of a need to feel special, or are merely seeking attention. DID (Disocciative Identity Disorder) is still highly controversial, not only in that mental health professionals squabble over subtle differences in qualifying symptoms, how it develops, or should best be treated, but, especially in the case of deliberate dissociation, whether or not it even exists.

The social ramifications of this conflict permeate not only the health care industry, but affect who gets insurance, what gets taught in universities, and what juries and judges believe or dismiss when confronted with PTSD or DID afflicted survivors. How can survivors get heard and healed while physicians, academicians and attorneys do battle in the Dark Ages?

Another reason for the current dearth of specialists is that they’re at risk for taking on patients whose families may retaliate against them for their client’s reactions to the healing process. They face the same credibility challenges academically, professionally and legally that their clients do socially because of the all-pervasive climate of denial. And this is no accident.

For the last 17 years, abusers have had a powerful ally. In 1992, the False Memory Syndrome Foundation, or FMSF, launched a movement to discredit survivors, and to vilify therapists who treat them.

FMSF was founded by Pamela and Peter Freyd after Peter had been accused of molestation by his daughter, Dr. Jennifer Freyd, Professor of Psychology at the University of Oregon. Two of the first board members, therapists Hollida Wakefield and Ralph Underwager, had to resign after publicly defending pedophilia. Many other board members, past and present, have CIA or military intelligence connections (Tavistock Institute trained Dr. Louis West, known for his CIA funded work on mind control techniques, among them).

FMSF tactics include suing therapists for malpractice and filing amicus briefs (documents filed by someone not a party to the case) in court cases relating to child abuse. But the real success story here is their ability to manipulate public perception. Mike Stanton, writing for the Columbia Journalism Review, summarized this phenomenon: “The foundation is an aggressive, well-financed p.r. (sic) machine adept at manipulating the press, harassing its critics, and mobilizing a diverse army of psychiatrists, outspoken academics, expert defense witnesses, litigious lawyers, Freud bashers, critics of psychotherapy, and devastated parents.”

He goes on to note: “A study published (in 1996) by a University of Michigan sociologist, Katherine Beckett, found a sharp shift in how four leading magazines — Time, Newsweek, U.S. News & World Report, and People — treated sexual abuse. In 1991, more than 80% of the coverage was weighted toward stories of survivors, with recovered memory taken for granted and questionable therapy virtually ignored. By 1994, more than 80% of the coverage focused on false accusations, often involving supposedly false memory.”

There is now an FMSF chapter in every state.

Of the brave souls who choose to defy the status quo and specialize in the field of trauma, it will be the minority who fully comprehend and acknowledge the extremities to which perpetrators are capable of going to achieve their ends, and especially how well they may be organized and interconnected. As a result, a client often has to contend with an ever-present layer of resistance to the credibility of her or his memories, and/or her or his apparently baffling constellation of symptoms, which impinges on any therapeutic value the telling of their stories might otherwise have.

Elie Wiesel, novelist and Holocaust survivor, wrote: “When human beings tell victims, who have suffered excruciating pain and loss that their pain and loss were illusions, they are committing the greatest indignity humans can inflict on another.”

There are other challenges for a survivor in a therapeutic relationship even if that therapist is well qualified to treat post-traumatic symptoms, and honors their integrity and courage. The intrinsic trust issues a survivor brings to the table can be debilitating, and the power differential inherent in the traditional client-therapist dynamic can serve to undermine trust and create an atmosphere that impedes the healing process on many levels. In cases where survivors were tortured, programmed or experimented upon by psychologists, psychiatrists or other medically trained personnel, trusting any kind of therapist or doctor can require an enormous leap of faith.

Survivors who have been institutionalized may endure fates much worse than being discredited and dismissed socially. The many ways in which survivors have been re-traumatized while in institutional care have been well documented. They often suffer from psychological abuse such as being controlled, isolated, stigmatized, misdiagnosed, etc. They may also be physically abused: physically or chemically restrained, made to strip, overmedicated or given dangerous psychotropic medication, among other deplorable violations. And again, survivors of medical experiments or medical treatments designed to induce memory loss and compliance are especially vulnerable to institutional re-traumatization.

Further undermining faith in these traditional modes of healing for mind-control victims is the fact that numerous doctors, universities and hospitals, from the earliest days of psychiatric studies, were involved in sadistic experimentation. For example, Ewen Cameron, arguably the most well known mind-control doctor for the CIA, was also the President of the American Psychiatric Association from 1952 to 1953.

“…if you faced the death of bombs and bullets
you did not do it with a banner,
you did it with only a hat to
cover your heart.
You did not fondle the weakness inside you
though it was there.
Your courage was a small coal
that you kept swallowing.
If your buddy saved you
and died himself in so doing,
then his courage was not courage,
it was love; love as simple as shaving soap.

Later,
if you have endured a great despair,
then you did it alone…”

-Anne Sexton, excerpt from Courage, from The Awful Rowing Toward God

The Awful Rowing Toward God was the last book poet Anne Sexton wrote before taking her own life. Her long time therapist was Dr. Martin T. Orne. Dr. Orne was a founding member of FMSF, a senior CIA researcher, and is known for performing CIA funded mind control experiments.

SEE NO EVIL

“The major goal of the Cold War mind control programs was to create dissociative symptoms and disorders, including full multiple personality disorder”

– Colin Ross, Bluebird: Deliberate Creation of Multiple Personality by Psychiatrists

“‘Monarch’ refers to young people in America who were victims of mind control experiments run either by U.S. government agencies such as the Central Intelligence Agency, or military intelligence agencies. The story told by Monarch victims… Is that they were tortured for the purpose of creating “multiple personalities” within them. These multiple personalities could then be programmed as desired – as spies, “drug mules,” prostitutes, or assassins.”

– Senator John W. DeCamp, excerpt from The Franklin Cover-Up, Child Abuse, Satanism, and Murder in Nebraska[vii]

“…Perhaps most disturbing of all was the fact that the extent of experimentation on human subjects was unknown. The records of all these activities were destroyed in January 1973, at the instruction of then CIA Director Richard Helms.”

-Senator Edward Kennedy, from his opening remarks at the 1977 Church Committee hearings concerning project MKUltra

The average US citizen, understandably, has almost no cultural frame of reference for processing personal histories involving extreme abuse, especially cult, secret society and government atrocities like ritual abuse and institutionalized mind control. Groundbreaking academic lectures[viii] go unacknowledged, mainstream publishers won’t touch manuscripts written by survivors, and their shocking testimonies[ix] are suppressed. Carol Rutz, author of A Nation Betrayed, and one of the four researchers behind the Extreme Abuse Survey, describes the on-line resistance to the EAS going forward in her 2007 presentation of the survey results at SMART’s[x] 10th Annual Ritual Abuse, Secretive Organizations and Mind Control Conference:

“I would like to give you an idea of how fearful some people were that this survey would be successfully carried out. The whole system we had in place online resisted a series of port scanning attacks which raised peak in the first week. We were close to denial of service because we lost bandwidth due to ongoing attacks which were about 9,000 per hour. Mid March we had an elaborate brute force attack to the Windows server. Not being a techie, that is as much as I can explain. Thank goodness we had a series of servers in place that protected all data.”[xi]

Likewise, official government documents showing direct evidence of sponsorship of mind control experimentation[xii] is given no press whatsoever. The silence in the media on these topics is deafening.

Why don’t these kinds of atrocities committed against children and other disempowered citizens make CNN? As many adult survivors of organized crime syndicates know all too well, leaders in these organizations typically also own corporations, or hold powerful positions in the corporate world, and/or positions of high authority in civilian or military government. Children and adults who have been programmed as sex slaves, couriers, spies or assassins are valuable assets to the entities that developed them. The sexual exploitation of children is a highly lucrative industry, and deliberately dissociated government and military operatives[xiii] serve as politically and militarily invaluable means of maintaining power and control. Clandestine government and corporate operations that rely on this invisible slave force are not about to let the proverbial cat out of the bag. The FMSF PR machine is in good company.

It has been widely reported that by the end of 2008 there were only six companies dominating US media. This concentration of corporate media ownership means that there are only a few organizations dictating what makes the news for the majority of Americans. Among other deeply unfortunate social ramifications of this state of affairs is the fact that mainstream media are rendered far more vulnerable to manipulation by the corrupt powers that be.[xiv]

One major impediment to letting the truth about extreme abuse see the light of day in mainstream media is outright ownership of telecommunications corporations by organized criminals. The general demise of the free press can be partly attributed to a systematic corrosion of regulations and safeguards, executed by the same entities that benefit most from the ensuing malleability of the reality projected by the mass media: huge corporations, political ideologues and the military-industrial complex.

“Somebody, sometime has got to take a stand and say democracy cannot survive, much less thrive with the level of big corporate and big government interference and intimidation in news.”

-Dan Rather on “Larry King Live,” 9-20-07

The current musical chairs approach to political office further degrades the distinction between corporate and government objectives. Former high profile politicians serve on boards of powerful corporations, forming intricate networks linking corporate media to military, congressional and executive branches of the US government. Some then re-enter the political arena, completing the “revolving door” cycle. Conversely, many corporate executives become politicians, and around and around it goes.[xv]

Each of the six remaining corporate media behemoths has direct ties, through interlocking directorates and common shareholders, with other giant corporations,[xvi] many of which are government contractors. And some corporations that are government contractors flat out own media corporations, like GE owning NBC.

There are currently more government contractors out there than ever before. Tim Shorrock, reporting for Salon.com, wrote the following in an article published in 2007: “On May 14, at an industry conference in Colorado sponsored by the Defense Intelligence Agency, the U.S. government revealed for the first time how much of its classified intelligence budget is spent on private contracts: a whopping 70%.”

There are now more private contractors working for the federal government than actual government employees; the line between corporate and government interests has all but vanished. And the entities responsible for this phenomenon are the same entities that have historically exploited the disempowered to further their agenda of political and social control.

Underworld atrocities involving political, military or commercial exploitation of children are not going to make the 10:00 news.

But why would this corporatocracy bother to discredit survivors who remember previously repressed trauma if that trauma were an isolated incident, perpetrated by a solitary criminal? Or people anywhere on the spectrum of dissociative “disorders”? They have to squelch the whole notion of repressed memories and dissociative identities, and especially the fact that a person can be deliberately split for sadistic reasons.

If the average citizen understood the basic psychodynamics of extreme trauma, they would be more likely to give credence to survivors’ memories in general. Public pressure would be brought to bear on the legal justice system to respond accordingly, which would inevitably lead to public exposure and criminal convictions. This could ultimately lead to large networks of corruption collapsing.

General social acceptance and understanding of the manifestations of psychological trauma represent a serious threat to those whose power, wealth and ambitions depend on survivors remaining invisible and discredited.

“Go, go, go said the bird: human kind

cannot bear very much reality.”

– T.S. Eliot, from Burnt Norton

Author David Ray Griffin coined the phrase “nationalist faith” to describe the phenomenon of categorical denial, in the face of irrefutable, relevant evidence, of incidents wherein governments have acted against their own citizens. This unconscious, inner framing of how the world works, of what is and isn’t possible according to unprocessed beliefs, is a big part of the brick wall survivors face when they try to speak their truths.

The brutal, hidden world of organized criminal networks that survivors understand intimately is a completely invisible and, more importantly, impossible reality to the majority of the population. The same can be said of extreme domestic violence. No father would prostitute his own daughter, or sell her to a sadistic doctor. There’s no such thing as a satanic cult, because no human being would worship evil. The U.S. military would never torture a child until their mind splintered into pieces to build a super spy, or an assassin. Governments could never traffic innocent children with the same indifference with which they illegally traffic arms or illegal drugs. But they do.

Another deterrent to widespread acceptance of survivors’ post trauma experience is based on a simple truth about human nature: it’s very sad and unpleasant to hear about crimes perpetrated against children. It’s easier to pretend it doesn’t happen than to acknowledge it and feel powerless to stop it.

Judith Herman wrote, in Trauma and Recovery: “It is very tempting to take the side of the perpetrator. All the perpetrator asks is that the bystander do NOTHING…the victim, on the contrary, asks the bystander to share the burden of pain. The victim demands action, engagement and remembering.”

STRENGTH IN NUMBERS

If anything, standard therapeutic practice, in its current form, discourages survivors from collaboration. This is due, in part, to the prevailing myth that survivors’ memories and accounts are fragile and susceptible to distortion by exposure to other survivors’ histories. This can be seen as an extension of the misperception that survivors, especially of mind control, are by nature super-suggestible.

This is a particularly cruel bias in light of the fact that they have sustained abuse so violent in nature that they were pushed to the limit of integration and had to split from the experience (a natural, adaptive response). To suggest that they’re somehow innately more impressionable and gullible than a “normal” person is to sadistically dismiss the courage and strength it took to survive.

These misconceptions only serve to exacerbate the debilitating sequestering of a population already condemned to social isolation through denial of both their symptoms and the underlying causes. Also, these biases obviously have the disturbing effect of protecting the perpetrators. One survivor who bears witness to being tortured or trafficked is “delusional,” two survivors pointing at the same perpetrator is a law suit, and they know it.

“There was a theft.

That much I am told.

I was abandoned.

That much I know.

I was forced backward.

I was forced forward.

I was passed hand to hand

like a bowl of fruit.

Each night I am nailed into place

and forget who I am”

-Anne Sexton, from Briar Rose (Sleeping Beauty)

The perpetrator of an atrocity steals many things from the victim: innocence, power, meaning, hope and faith among them. But the giant disconnect the victim experiences is perhaps the most tragic loss of all. Because no one can heal in isolation.

The disconnects happen on every level. Internally, the sensory and emotional impressions of the trauma can be shattered into oddly isolated states. The victim can suffer from identity fracturing and disintegration. Attachments to family and friends can be breached, and victims often feel socially detached in general. The dissociations are profound. That’s why it’s so vital that survivors reach out and communicate with one another; it’s why survivor solidarity can be such a profoundly healing experience. And what heals survivors of society’s darkest deeds heals society.

BELL RINGING

“Ring the bells that still can ring

Forget your perfect offering

There is a crack, a crack in everything

That’s how the light gets in.”

-Leonard Cohen, from Anthem

Since the media, the legal justice system, the scientific community, and the health provider industry have all failed spectacularly to comprehend, acknowledge and communicate the truth about post-trauma experience, deliberate dissociation, and the atrocities that spawn “survivors,” the onus is on survivors themselves to enlighten society.

As Emma Goldman wrote, “The most violent element of society is ignorance.” As long as the nature of the aftermath of psychological trauma is one of society’s best kept secrets, perpetrators of atrocities will prevail.

General awareness of survivors’ challenges and dilemmas has the awesome potential to lead not only to personal justice on a small scale, but ultimately to social justice on a global scale. This is the precious gift survivors have to give, through their courage, integrity and hope: the protection of future generations of innocent children.  

“Whenever I despair, I remember that the way of truth and love has always won. There may be tyrants and murderers, and for a time, they may seem invincible, but in the end, they always fail. Think of it – always.”

-Mahatma Gandhi


Notes

[i] Even the number of reported missing children is staggering: According to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, “Every year in America an estimated 800,000 children are reported missing, more than 2,000 children each day.  Of that number, 200,000 are abducted by family members, and 58,000 are abducted by non-family members. The primary motive for non-family abductions is sexual.  Each year 115 children are the victims of the most serious abductions, taken by non-family members and either murdered, held for ransom, or taken with the intent to keep.”

http://www.missingkids.com/missingkids/servlet/NewsEventServlet?LanguageCountry=en_US&PageId=4046

[ii] In 2006, Michigan Governor Jennifer M. Granholm signed two bills into legislation that made torture a criminal act. See: http://www.michigan.gov/gov/0,1607,7-168-23442_21974-133334–,00.html

[iii] TORTURE OF CANADIAN WOMEN BY NON-STATE ACTORS IN THE PRIVATE SPHERE: A SHADOW REPORT (March, 2008) – Jeanne Sarson, RN, BScN, MEd, Linda MacDonald, RN, BN, MEd. Available: http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/cedaw/docs/ngos/VOWCanada42.pdf

Their incredible website: http://www.ritualabusetorture.org/

[iv] Helen McGonigle, a Connecticut attorney and fearless survivor advocate, made the following observation (emphasis hers):

“…the worldwide proliferation of the multi-billion dollar pornography industry, internet child porn rings, sex trafficking, all combined with the millions of unregistered births, provides an ample supply of potential victims. As a Senior State Department adviser on trafficking in persons was quoted: “we’re not finding victims in the United States because we’re not looking for them”.

– From The Girls Next Door, New York Times Magazine January 25, 2004.

[v] 1,471 adult survivors of extreme abuse from more than 30 countries participated in this groundbreaking on-line survey developed by Carol Rutz, Wanda Karriker, Thorsten Becker and Bettina Overkamp: http://extreme-abuse-survey.net/

See also: Wanda Karriker’s 2007 United Nations presentation: http://extreme-abuse-survey.net/survey.php?en=d and her 2008 presentation of highlights from the EAS trilogy: http://ritualabuse.us/smart-conference/conf08/highlights-extreme-abuse-survey/

[vi] It’s now commonly referred to as PTSS, or post-traumatic stress syndrome, as the term “disorder” is a misnomer in the sense that it implies that there’s something inherently wrong with the survivor. In fact, it’s a sane, adaptive response to an overwhelmingly crazy event. The same can be said for DID, but sadly, as of yet, isn’t.

[vii] Conspiracy of Silence, the hour long documentary about this scandal involving the typical constellation of survivor horrors: satanic ritual abuse, mind control, child trafficking, senators, major media corporations and, of course, the CIA, was scheduled to air May 3, 1994, on the Discovery Channel, but was cancelled unexpectedly. A new book, The Franklin Scandal,  about the scandal and the ensuing cover-up was published by investigative journalist Nick Bryant this year (2009).

[viii] “The Greenbaum Speech” by Dr. Corydon Hammond is a prime example: http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_mindcon03.htm

[ix] From: http://web.archive.org/web/20070405174814/www.aches-mc.org/mind_control.html:

“In March of 1995, Valerie Wolf, M.S.W., and two of her clients who had been subjected to mind control experimentation since early childhood appeared before the President’s Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments. After consulting with forty other therapists across the country (the majority of whom remained anonymous for reasons of personal safety), Ms. Wolf documented in writing the names of the research projects and the names of the people involved.

The two survivors, Claudia Mullen and Chris DeNicola Ebner, testified that as victims they experienced electric shock, hallucinogens, dislocation of limbs, sadistic acts of pedophilia, hypnosis and sensory deprivation. Often they were locked in cages for long periods of time. At the conclusion of the Presidential Hearing, the Committee recommended further exploration of the mind control experimentation on unwitting human subjects. It has been over a year and a half since this recommendation was made, but nothing further has been done by the President’s Advisory Committee. You will not be surprised to learn that there has been no coverage or investigation by the mainstream media despite the testimony provided by Wolf, Mullen and Ebner.”

[x] SMART: http://ritualabuse.us/

[xi] Carol Rutz’s presentation:

http://ritualabuse.us/smart-conference/conf07/the-world-will-know-results-of-the-2007-international-survey-for-adult-survivors-of-extreme-abuse/

[xii] Government documentation of mind control experiments: http://web.archive.org/web/20060613070613/parascope.com/ds/mkultradocs.htm

[xiii] See Ron Patton’s overview of  Monarch training: http://web.archive.org/web/20070405152034/www.aches-mc.org/monarch.html

[xiv] A prime example of an organization that has a lot to gain and everything to lose by influencing popular media is the quintessentially metastatic Tavistock Institute. This London-based institution, with its long history of colluding with the MI6 and CIA on mind control techniques, is known both as the “mother of all propaganda ministries” (to quote Dr. John Coleman, author of The Tavistock Institute of Human Relations) and the world center for foundation ideology. It has been reported that the institute currently operates a multibillion dollar a year network of foundations in the US, which in turn are enmeshed with a multitude of giant corporations.

[xv] One particularly egregious example is the Washington D.C. based private equity firm, the Carlyle Group. Run by leading members of Bush Senior’s presidential administration, Carlyle is the largest private equity firm in the world, and the nation’s 11th largest defense contractor. In 2008, Booz Allen Hamilton, one of CIA’s major contractors, sold a majority stake in the US government business to The Carlyle Group for $2.54 billion.

Portfolio telecommunication companies include Dex Media, the former directories business of Qwest Communications, and Insight Communications, the ninth largest cable company in the U.S.

Former FCC Chairman William E. Kennard is now managing director of Carlyle Group’s telecommunication and media practice. He’s also on the New York Times Company board of directors. Editor-in-chief of Time magazine from 1995 – 2005, Norman Pearlstine is Carlyle’s telecommunications and media group senior advisor.

Carlyle company director is Daniel Akerson, a former board member of AOL Time Warner (CNN is owned by Time Warner.) Frank Carlucci, Carlyle Chairman and Chairman Emeritus from 1987 to 2005, was a former Deputy Director of the CIA, and former US Secretary of Defense under Reagan.

The elder President Bush, (also former CIA Director) was a senior advisor until he retired in 2003 amid conflict-of-interest allegations. He’s currently on retainer. President George W. Bush served on the Board of Directors of Caterair, one of Carlyle’s first acquisitions. Former secretary of state James Baker was senior Carlyle Senior Counsel until 2005.

[xvi] See Project Censored’s 2009 Media Map of Major Media Ownership and Governance:

http://www.projectcensored.org/censorship/media-map/

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Survivors of Extreme Abuse: The Awful Rowing Toward Social Emancipation

The Official Story vs. Reality: Survivors as Whistleblowers

S.M.A.R.T. Conference

August 2011

The Official Story vs. Reality: Survivors as Whistleblowers

Carmen Holiday

Hi everybody. It’s a great honor to be here again, and I want to thank Neil for working so hard year after year to create this rare space for us, where we can come together and forge an ever stronger community. It’s an honor to be in the same room with so many extraordinary human beings, and I’m grateful to you all for making your way here.

I’m going to talk about survivors as whistleblowers today, and this time I’ll try to keep the weeping to a bare minimum. I’d like to dedicate this talk to my dear friend’s beautiful twins, Natalie and Jeffery.

What follows are my personal opinions and views, and all allegations are my own unless otherwise noted.

Holocaust survivor Viktor Frankl once wrote:

We who lived in concentration camps can remember the men who walked through the huts comforting others, giving away their last piece of bread. They may have been few in number, but they offer sufficient proof that everything can be taken from a man but one thing: the last of the human freedoms – to choose one’s attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one’s own way.

In spite of everything our perpetrators tried to take from us – power, meaning, hope and faith – we had the heart and resourcefulness to hang onto our humanity. What we choose to do with our hard fought freedom can help us restore much of what was lost to us, and what continues to be lost to us as a society, if we choose to tell the truth.

Several years ago, a movie came out called The Truman Show. It was about a guy who lived in a world that was actually an enormous studio set, but he didn’t know it. Natural elements, community and relationships were all carefully orchestrated to keep Truman locked in the belief that he was in a “normal” world, having a “normal” life, when in fact it was all meant to exploit his ongoing life story for a nationwide television audience.

We, as survivors of the darkest deeds of our society, are in a unique position to expose the lies those in power have imposed upon us. We have a vantage point unfamiliar, even unfathomable to our fellow citizens, because we’ve been dragged outside the set. If anyone can help our allegorical Truman see the hidden seams of his world, it’s us.

Peter Phillips, Professor of Sociology and Director of an organization called Project Censored, has recently expressed great dismay over what he describes as American citizens’ inability to distinguish fact from fiction. In an article called “Truth Emergency: Inside the Military Industrial Media Empire,” he writes:

How can this mass ignorance and corporate media deception exist in the United States of America, and what impact does this have on peace and social justice movements in the country? … In the United States today, the rift between reality and reporting has reached its end. There is no longer a mere credibility gap, but rather a literal Truth Emergency.

The chasm between the reality projected in corporate media and what’s really happening on the ground has never represented a more serious threat. Because the current trifecta of political, economic and ecological crises we face today has been so effectively masked and distorted that even now, with basic civil rights vanishing over the horizon, and life on our planet imperiled, the majority of Americans still generally believe what they see, hear and read in corporate sponsored media, which is essentially that the corporatocracy’s interests and the people’s interests are one and the same.

In a cynical coup of misdirection, mainstream media outlets dangle fluffy faux news and disinformation in front of consumers while the ruling elite carefully pull the rug out from under them, to the point where Americans seem to be more informed about the trifecta of Brad Pitt, Angelia Jolie and Jennifer Anniston than about the true current state of affairs.

As survivors of outrageous corruption and homegrown atrocities, we constitute an invaluable resource as potential agents of change. We have long been aware of a “truth emergency” in this country. And we’ve witnessed the darkest, most egregious violations of human rights imaginable, having had the misfortune of getting caught up in the greasy undercarriage of a society that believes itself to be humane and civilized.

So who could be in a better position to expose systemic corruption of our trusted institutions? Who better than those of us who have seen what we’ve seen to point out the extreme hypocrisy of those in power?

Well, as fate would have it, this moment in US history happens to be a tricky moment for whistleblowers in general. Julian Assange and Bradley Manning are both facing possible death sentences for leaking thousands of diplomatic cables through Wikileaks. And the Obama administration’s reactive crackdown on whistleblowers has been of historic proportions.

Blowing the whistle on official corruption is almost always exponentially more dicey for us, because what we know is so much more damning and dangerous than what your garden variety whistleblower knows.

We’re also at a disadvantage because we usually have to start from scratch when we try to expose our perpetrators, because people don’t generally have any realistic frame of reference for our stories. And this general ignorance isn’t accidental; the “official story” almost always leaves out the chapters on ritual abuse and mind control all together.

So, who does control the narrative, how is this social denial of our experiences rendered so absolute? Well, to quote Peter Phillips again: “Not only is the corporate media deeply interlocked with the military industrial complex and global dominance policy elites in the US, but the media is increasingly dependent on various governmental and corporate sources of news.”

And when the news is centralized in this way, the elite get to control the language, which is to say, they get to frame our collective sense of reality. They have the power to control awareness and attention, much as they did to us, except in terms of scale. And the part about the torture. As John leCarre, the famous British novelist put it, “the American public is not merely being misled. It is being browbeaten and kept in a state of ignorance and fear.”

So the Truman Show world of conventional wisdom is that DID doesn’t exist, or if it does, it’s an extremely rare phenomenon. Ritual abuse doesn’t exist at all, and mind control was a fleeting fancy of rogue and overzealous CIA spooks in the mid 20th century that had something to do with LSD, and didn’t really go anywhere. If one person claims to be multiple, or to have suffered ritualized abuse, they’re either seeking attention or are delusional, and if a community claims to have ritual abuse perpetrators in their midst they’re suffering from mass hysteria.

In 1994, when the backlash against victims of extreme abuse and their advocates was in full swing, Daniel Goleman, author of Emotional IQ, summed up the official story about ritual abuse in an article published in the New York Times. He writes:

Tales of satanic ritual abuse, with well-organized cults sacrificing animals and babies and engaging in sexual perversion and cannibalism, is the stuff of tabloid television. Now the first empirical study of its actual prevalence, based on information from district attorneys, social service workers, police officials and psychotherapists, suggests that these tales are just that — figments of imagination.

And he goes on to say: “The survey found that there was not a single case where there was clear corroborating evidence for the most common accusation, that there was a well-organized intergenerational satanic cult.” So why would the “most common accusation” be so common? He states in this article that there had been thousands of such cases reported.

Goleman goes on to quote psychiatrist Bennett Braun: “There’s clearly been a contagion, a contamination of what people say in therapy because of what they see on TV or read about satanic ritual abuse.” So, we were either coerced by dodgy therapists, whose possible motives are rarely addressed, or we’ve snatched a story from TV or from books, and again for reasons unknown, adopted them as our own.

Hal Pepinsky, professor of criminal justice and member of the North America Truth and Reconciliation Coalition, or NATRC, has offered this astute observation:

If these narratives are essentially fabricated, they must have been fabricated in many different ways at once. It would require a more elaborate “conspiracy” to account for how similar narratives could be falsely implanted in so many survivors’ minds in so many different ways … than to account for how so many cults and mind control programmers could operate essentially in secret, with impunity.

Well Goleman’s galling article goes on to quote Dr. Goodman, the psychologist who directed the survey: “After scouring the country, we found no evidence for large-scale cults that sexually abuse children.” But, she added, her group did find “convincing evidence of lone perpetrators or couples who say they are involved with Satan or use the claim to intimidate victims.”

Ritual abuse crimes have now been well-documented, cases in which there have been criminal convictions and so forth, and have been extensively catalogued in Neil’s S.M.A.R.T. web pages, so corroboration is out there.

But these cases rarely get widespread exposure in the press, and the ones that do break through that firewall are universally framed as one-offs, as in the small concession Goreman’s article makes: that they’re independent perpetrators committing isolated crimes. And in a moment we’ll revisit what colossal lengths the power-brokers will go to to suppress a story when a whistleblower dares to expose the whole kit and caboodle.

Wikipedia’s current entry on Satanic ritual abuse, no less appalling than Goreman’s ’94 sampling, shows that in terms of mainstream disinformation, not much progress has been made. Here are some excerpts:

Satanic ritual abuse … refers to a moral panic that originated in the United States in the 1980s, spreading throughout the country and eventually to many parts of the world, before subsiding in the late 1990s … Official investigations produced no evidence of widespread conspiracies … only a small number of verified crimes have even remote similarities to tales of SRA.

The reason “official investigations” haven’t produced any evidence of widespread corruption is that official investigators are too often criminal conspirators themselves. And when they get caught with their hands in the cookie jar, as in the case of the Finders, and other scandals where official investigative cover-ups were documented, the popular press turns a blind eye.

And speaking of sins of omission, mind control allegations and relevant documentation don’t even warrant press exposure when there’s an official government hearing on the topic, as was the case the ’95 hearings before the President’s Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments.

Another example of this unfortunate phenomenon just played out this past June, when a 2009 class action suit filed by Viet Nam vets against the CIA and other government agencies was finally dismissed. The suit claimed they experimented on at least 7,800 soldiers during the cold war, mainly at Edgewood Arsenal and Fort Detrick, and exposed them to drugs and electronic implants. If you haven’t heard about this, it’s probably because mainstream media categorically ignored it.

Projects named in this suit included “Bluebird,” “Artichoke” and “MKUltra.” Alleged goals of the projects included controlling human behavior, and developing drugs that would cause confusion and induce hypnosis. The veterans say that some of the soldiers suffered from paranoia, grand mal seizures and epileptic seizures, and some soldiers died.

Perhaps not as compelling as Brad Pitt and Angelia Jolie’s latest domestic squabble, but information the public probably should have, nonetheless.

Hollywood has been right up there with news media in terms of manipulating public perception. Obvious big screen tactics include presenting a protagonist who believes they’ve been a victim of mind control and then condemning them as a lunatic, as happens in Shutter Island or, in a more subtle approach, setting up a protagonist as a victim of mind control, but glamorizing and romanticizing their role, and sanitizing the context, as they do in the Bourne series and in Salt.

In the case of Jason Bourne, they go so far as to show him being tortured as part of his training process, but they have him volunteering, consenting to this program as a fully conscious adult, and the motivating factor is that it’s all for a good cause, it’s an honorable, noble endeavor. And the other huge distortion there is that the parties involved in illegal operations are framed as a rogue element, a deviation from the moral and principled main body.

As far as mind control operations are concerned, documented players like Allen Dulles and Sidney Gottleib were no rogue operatives. The CIA was founded by men on record as being involved in these projects, and it was the CIA director himself, Richard Helms, who ordered the MKUltra files destroyed. So there’s no plausible deniability there to speak of.

Some feature films include fairly accurate details about our experiences, which on the face of it seems counterproductive in terms of denying our stories, but on the other hand, you can’t accuse a victim of having derived their fantastical claims from watching too many movies if there aren’t any movies like that out there.

Another part of that equation has to do with what the CIA historically referred to as a “limited hang-out.” This propaganda technique involves giving away some legit information in order to effectively hide a larger truth. In some cases that means putting information out there that’s 99% accurate, but then adding a few drops of poison to the mix that essentially negate or seriously undermine the real story.

And speaking of the CIA, or as I call it, the “Freemason mafia,” the way they’re portrayed in Hollywood in general seriously undermines the credibility of whistleblowers who’ve been victimized by them. Like the iconic James Bond, CIA assets are usually portrayed as classy, upstanding gentlemen whose mad skills enable them to get the upper hand on evil antagonists, who are well deserving of their terrible fates.

I think it’s safe to say those of us who were allegedly co-opted into the intelligence world as children generally knew them more as manipulative liars, child rapists, and cold-blooded killers.

Shortly before his death, retired CIA operative George White, an especially crass individual by all accounts, described his career in a letter to his former boss, Gottlieb, as “Fun, fun, fun. Where else could a red-blooded American boy lie, kill, cheat, steal, rape and pillage with the sanction and blessing of the all highest?”

The sexy and glamorous work agents do on the big screen is inevitably motivated by an honorable and urgent need to protect the state. And of course there’s nothing glamorous or honorable about what they did to us, or about what deliberately dissociated assassins or death squads really do, or whom they really do it for.

A third major piece of subterfuge in the popular media regarding the CIA is that it’s a highly centralized organization, represented by one or two super agents. And they’re at Langley testing cool gadgets. The reality is that right now there are an estimated 854,000 people in our country walking around with top secret security clearances from one intelligence agency or another, and that of those people, 265,000 are private contractors.

So the net result of the Hollywood spin is that if a survivor discloses a history of abuse involving the CIA, the knee-jerk reaction is likely to be that no one they know could possibly have anything to do with that organization, even that no one in their town could be associated with them; it almost has a mythical status in that regard.

TV is as rife as the big screen with disinformation and not-so-subtle distortions. To take the most obvious example I’m aware of, the series Fringe is a paragon of re-framing and shameless propagandizing. (It’s also loaded with blatant triggers and thought control related terminology, so consumer beware.)

The series features a young woman who works for the FBI as a special agent, Agent Olivia Dunham, all business, who is teamed up with an old man who turns out to be one of the Harvard mind control doctors who worked on her as a child, Walter Bishop. Bishop is portrayed as a charming and eccentric sympathetic character.

In an episode called “The Dreamscape,” he plays some archival footage from his early days for his FBI cohorts. In a blatant attempt to normalize something that would otherwise be viewed as repugnant, they show him chuckling at images of a hypnotized young man holding his arm out as the doctor presses an ice cube to his skin, while persuading him that it was burning coal. The man reacts as if he’s been burnt, and they cut to a close up of his skin turning red and blistering dramatically. The doctor says “Cruel, I suppose, but very enlightening.”

In an episode called “The Road Not Taken,” Agent Dunham, who gradually remembers bits and pieces of her history with the doctor, confronts him about what he did to her. Walter’s response is: “We were trying to help. We meant no harm.”

Dunham says: “No harm? You were drugging children, Walter. Why did you do it?”

Walter’s voice breaks with emotion: “We were trying to prepare you – to make you capable. Able. Something terrible is coming.”

Dunham: “What?”

Walter: “I don’t know.”

By the end of this scene, he breaks down crying. Back in his basement lab at Harvard, he plows through old notes until he finds what he’s looking for and reads it aloud: “We must nurture them, and protect them. We must prepare them so they can one day protect us.”

In the next episode, Dunham apologizes for being “so hard” on him. And all of this is brought to you by a production company called Bad Robot.

So, the official story that’s been rolled out in the media is that ritual abuse is nonexistent except in rare cases where a psychotic couple has tormented a child spontaneously and inexplicably in much the same way other psychotic couples have been known to do. The CIA is all glam and righteousness, and mind control, if it ever really happened at all, was perpetrated by compassionate doctors who were just looking out for the best interests of their subjects and countrymen.

So we’ve really got our work cut out for us.

Well, thanks to an ever-increasing number of brave and determined survivors and their allies, there’s a hard-fought track record from which much can be learned. For example, many survivors have stepped up and written autobiographies, including invaluable recent contributions like those of David Shurter, Janet Thomas, Dave Silvey and Anne Johnson Davis.

Davis’ book, Hell Minus One, published in 2008, was the result of seven years’ hard work, and marked the first time a survivor had succeeded in garnering signed confessions from perpetrators of ritual abuse: her own parents. The personal risks she took, and the sacrifices she made to get the truth out are exemplified in this passage describing her experience of writing letters detailing her abuse:

Each time I sat down to write another letter to the stake president, I had to force myself to move through paralyzing fear … As I read what I had written, tears welled up from my heart and flowed down my face. I could barely see what I was typing … Underneath it all, I was disturbed and intimidated by the realization that, at any time, my abusers could shoot me or someone I loved. I was afraid for the safety of my children, my husband and me. Though my mind wanted to take the words back, I was determined to speak the truth and withhold nothing.

Very tragically, we lost Anne last summer.

Other courageous, precedent-setting attempts to break through the silence include masterful works of art, as the talented Lynn Schirmer has shared, public lectures and personal testimonials. We have Dr. Corydon Hammond’s groundbreaking “Greenbaum Speech,” Valerie Wolf’s, Claudia Mullen’s and Chris Ebner’s incredible testimonies from the ’95 Presidential Hearing, and we have Trish Fotherington and her therapist Ellen Lacter’s amazing, inspirational documentary, among many other examples.

Perhaps the most iconic of all survivor whistleblowers is Alisha Owen, victim of a child pandering network for which the Franklin Credit Union was allegedly a front. Because the Franklin scandal is arguably the most well-documented survivor debacle to date, it’s especially instructive in terms of exposing both the extent of this kind corruption and the mechanics of oppression.

We’re very fortunate to have a meticulously researched record of this cover-up in the form of Nick Bryant’s amazing and mind-boggling book, The Franklin Scandal. To give you some idea of how well-researched this account is, the last 103 pages of his book are devoted to documentation.

For those of you unfamiliar with this particular scandal, it centered around Larry King, CEO of the Franklin Credit Union (whose early history, interestingly enough, included a stint for the air force handling “top secret” military communications). King was accused of looting $40 million dollars from Franklin, and in 1988, the credit union was raided by the authorities, and a Nebraska subcommittee was formed to investigate King’s misdeeds.

A number of people from child protection agencies came forward to say that state and federal law enforcement agencies had been categorically ignoring their reports concerning King’s interstate child pandering network, so the committee agreed to investigate these allegations as well. And thus begins the macabre and ultimately tragic epic battle between the victims of sadistic exploitation and their allies, and the wealthy and powerful.

As the committee was forming, one member, conservative Senator Loren Schmit, received an anonymous phone call warning him against pursuing the Franklin investigation because it would “reach to the highest levels of the Republican Party.”

By the time this gushing calamity plays itself out, longtime civil servants like Schmit will end up sacrificing their careers, and victims and their advocates will be plagued by threats, shuffled off to psychiatric facilities, shredded in the press, crucified in the courts, and several even die under suspicious circumstances.

The victims who came forward were absurdly out-gunned. Larry King is on record as having bragged that high-ranking military and intelligence officers attended his parties, and his social circle at the time reportedly included an attorney general, a governor, a former secretary of state, US congressmen, a US ambassador to the U.N., the HUD secretary, a former CIA director, a former president and George H.W. Bush himself.

Part of the gift survivors give when they risk telling the truth is that they force the hand of criminal networks by compelling them to come out of the shadows to take defensive action. Much can be learned by paying attention to who comes to bat to cover the backsides of their brethren, and how they do it.

Some of the alleged participants in this cover-up include the publisher of the Omaha World-Herald, the Omaha chief of police, the Nebraska attorney general, a US District Judge, a US Magistrate, one of our nation’s leading newspapers and a major television network. The full spectrum of folks who allegedly helped to silence victims and keep this story under wraps included teachers, school administrators, journalists, counselors, psychiatrists, politicians of every stripe and of course, the top of all Mafioso food chains, the banking industry, or as they’re now sometimes called the “banksters.”

The extent of the corruption was also betrayed by the drastic nature of the steps taken to hush people up. Among the suspicious deaths associated with Franklin were the kid brothers of two of the main witnesses, Alisha Owen and Troy Boner, and crack investigator Gary Caradori and his eight year-old son Alex.

As many of you know, Caradori’s private plane broke up in mid-air after he’d finally allegedly acquired solid evidence of King’s guilt: photos of his and his associate’s sadistic exploitation of children. His attaché case was never found.

The impetus for his search for these photographs had been that he’d heard through the grapevine that he was going to be set up as a fall guy because of evidence he’d uncovered. In The Franklin Scandal, Bryant quotes a letter Caradori wrote to an attorney requesting his representation. He writes:

“In short, what we have discovered is only a small part of a nationwide child exploitation network. It is obvious that the people behind this organization are powerful and ruthless, and are going to great lengths to keep this matter contained.” He further stated that the network extended “to the highest levels of the United States.”

And through it all, Owen and Owen alone refuses to recant her original testimony, throwing a giant monkey wrench into an otherwise neat and complete cover-up. In the face of what amounts to psychological warfare on the part of state and federal officials and the media, Owen never gives an inch, and, even more incredibly, never gives up. And what does she get for her trouble? She’s set up as a scapegoat designed to send a chilling message to other potential witnesses.

Owen was sentenced to 9 to 15 years in prison for perjury. She ended up doing more than nine years behind bars, two of them in solitary confinement. The first time she was up for parole it was granted unanimously, because of her impressive list of accomplishments while incarcerated.

In 1993, Senator Schmit lost his seat of twenty-four years, and this is his take on what it cost him personally to pursue the Franklin investigation in spite of dire warnings:

I had, I think, as distinguished a record as anyone could put together in twenty-four years – I was told that that would be curtailed, and it was … I was told I would have financial problems, and I did. The message was not lost on most of the politicians in Nebraska – I think the message that was delivered was that if any legislative committee ever tries to conduct a thorough investigation again, the same thing will happen. It has shaken my faith in the institution of government.

On the face of it, this story should have irresistible Hollywood appeal, so why isn’t it a feature film? Not for lack of trying. Bryant has pursued both feature film and documentary production, to no avail. What we have instead is a grainy, bootleg copy of the ‘94 Yorkshire Television version, Conspiracy of Silence, circulating in relative obscurity on the internet. Bryant has commented that “just about every major media personality in America has my book, and they won’t touch The Franklin Scandal.”

As he observes in his book:

The Franklin story is a cautionary warning for America – not only does it provide a glimpse of a stratum of government corruption that is opaque and unfathomable to the majority of Americans, it also demonstrates that the government, together with the media, have the potential to spin fictions into facts, and facts into fictions.

We need to stand up and fight that spin with everything we’ve got.

Whistleblowing is hardly foreign territory for many of us in this room. For some of us, just escaping a toxic system alone amounted to a threatening leak. And a number of us have experienced the wonders of blowing the whistle within the context of our families of origin.

In my childhood family, there were no blurry lines; there was no overlapping of criminally dysfunctional behavior and socially acceptable behavior. There was the version of reality with my parents’ stamp of approval on it, and there was the other one, which was basically an unmitigated nightmare. Like many other survivors I know, when I began to recover, years after physically leaving the family system, I dared to point out this unfortunate discrepancy.

Among other drastic measures, word went out to extended family, friends and in-laws that I was a raving lunatic. When my aunt and uncle came to visit shortly thereafter, my aunt was actually afraid to come into our house. And this strikes me as something of a microcosm of how we’re all socially marginalized, ostracized and otherized, as truth tellers.

Because my transition from ignorance to awareness of my dissociated past was relatively stark, it almost felt like one minute I was a suburban soccer mom, and the next minute I was sitting in a squeaky plastic chair at a conference, listening to “experts” talk about me and my ilk as if we were some terribly alien, almost unknowable subspecies of humanity. And the only way I can see around this absurd otherization is to get out there en masse and show them who we really are.

Historically, we’ve been branded and re-branded every which way, almost always skewing toward dehumanization. When we were being exploited as children, some of us were called “subjects,” “dwarfs,” “utensils,” “profits,” “contraband,” and worse. As adults, we’ve been labeled “crazy,” “paranoid,” “borderline,” “schizophrenic,” and “psychotic.”

We can’t continue to let them name us. We need a whole lot of us out there demystifying what it means to be dissociative, and not cowering in shame when the monsters responsible for this condition enjoy standard social status and apologize for nothing. We need to step up and name ourselves: “fellow human beings.”

As long as we let them hide us under the invisibility cloak of damning labels our stories will be hidden as well. As long as people dismiss us as human beings, our stories are also going to be dismissed, and the atrocities will continue unabated, and the perpetrators of these crimes will prevail.

I realize not all of us are at a place in our healing trajectory that’s conducive to speaking out, and for too many of us the risks are just too grave. I think in every case we need to be careful and brutally realistic in terms of analyzing and assessing true risks.

If you can’t speak out now, maybe you can support someone who can. No one can do this hard work without moral support. You can choose to help amplify someone else’s message, or you can choose to help to build networks to strengthen our community. You can join or support advocacy and activist organizations like the NATRC and Survivorship. And, as Neil pointed out this morning, you can do research and post informational blogs.

You can do educational outreach around dissociative issues; there’s a lot of resistance out there to the idea that many different people can inhabit one body. And there’s a pretty steep learning curve, there, in terms of how it can develop, how it can manifest, and how it can be used for sinister purposes.

You can help by committing yourself to healing. Mahatma Gandhi once said: “We are able to be of service to those who suffer only to the extent that we have been able to transform fear in our own lives.”

You can find someone out there who understands what you’ve been through and never, ever again believe you’re in this alone.

Dr. Valerie Sinason, director of the Clinic for Dissociative Studies, summed up a sad truth about victims of extreme abuse. She writes: “Legions of warriors are lost to society through suicide, psychiatric hospitals, addiction and prison.” My feeling is that those who are fortunate enough to be in a place where they can come forward have a special responsibility to those who, for one reason or another, aren’t able to, including children who are suffering helplessly right now.

As Simon Wiesenthal, a Holocaust survivor and famed Nazi hunter, once put it: “We, as survivors, have an obligation not only to the dead, but also to future generations: We must pass on to them our experiences.”

In 2005, Evangeline Wright wrote, in an article about mind control experimentation, that “the names and stories of the survivors are, for the most part, not found in court documents, government documents, or mainstream media reports. Instead, their stories are told in web postings and the notes of mental health workers, the outlets available to the marginalized and ignored.”

We need to drag our stories out of the therapists’ and clerics’ offices, out of the chat rooms, and into the daylight. We need to tell our neighbors, our hair stylists and our doctors what we know. Society at large can dismiss us in a facile way that one person who knows us is much less likely to manage.

And we need all hands on deck, every able-bodied, empowered survivor out there spreading the word, so that when a powerless child tries to tell her “safe parent,” or neighbor, or doctor that they’re being abused, they won’t be met with bewildered disbelief or admonishments, but with compassion and understanding. And their abusers will be held accountable.

Another reason we need the whole team to show up is that we need to dilute the risks any one of us takes. Right now there are people out there who’ve taken it upon themselves to risk it all for our cause. And, as most of you probably know, some of them have taken a lot of heat. No one survivor should have to bear the brunt of our collective secrets. Why leave it to a handful of survivors on the front lines to try to tear a hole in the Truman Show sky, when there are enough of us to tear down the whole set?

A number of courageous souls have made selfless sacrifices on our behalf. Shortly after Dr. Hammond gave his “Greenbaum Speech,” he had to stop speaking about mind control due to intense threats, and has remained quiet since. Loren Schmit sacrificed his career and his innocence, Alisha Owen sacrificed nine years of freedom, and Caradori and his son, and countless others have lost their lives. But what incredible gifts these warriors have given us. We need to ensure that their terrible sacrifices haven’t been in vain, and build on the momentum for which they’ve paid such a high price.

Valerie Sinason wrote, in her introduction to her revised edition of Attachment Trauma and Multiplicity:

Despite the clear description of what constitutes DID in the DSM-IV … this condition is still seen by some mental health professionals as a hysterical confabulation. It is 10-20 years too early for it to be picked up and dealt with well. What is it like to be suffering from something that is not yet adequately recognised? And not only is the DID not recognised, but the nature of the sadistic abuse that has caused it in the majority of cases is even less recognised.

Defenseless children being deliberately dissociated for syndicates that deal in children the same way they deal drugs and arms don’t have ten to twenty years to wait. Mothers who lie awake at night in agony, having lost their children in corrupt family courts to ex-husbands pimping for their fraternal orders don’t have ten to twenty years to wait. Victims of ritual abuse who’ve been hauled off to psychiatric institutions to be chemically incarcerated don’t have ten to twenty years to wait. We can’t afford to sit back and wait for the rest of the world to catch up. We need to start turning this ship of denial around now.

Through no fault of our own, our childhoods were hijacked and we were transformed from defenseless, innocent children into adults who are walking representations of unbearable realities. But we’re walking representations of something else, too, and that’s resilience – the strength of the human spirit.

Sometimes when I get triggered, I try to process the memories and feelings that come up by writing out whatever’s got a hold on me at that moment, and this often amounts to a sort of interview with one split or another.

So I want to share a slice of one of these with you, if you will indulge me, because I think it can serve as a reminder that our perpetrators weren’t always invincible, and we weren’t always successfully subjugated. Also, I think it illustrates, in a small way, how creative and resourceful we all were, by managing split-off parts of ourselves to survive the impossible and hang onto our humanity.

The context is that this split who was triggered, a young teenage girl, and others were allegedly taken to a Freemason camp. So here she’s talking about her main doctor at that point, a former Nazi war criminal.

She says: “He damn near starved us to death in one camp. We was buried under some kind of rubbish for a while, too, to see what would happen to us. There was rats there too in the garbage dump around us. It took a long time, that one. We buried ourselves in the dung heap to keep warm at night, and we had each other. (And here she names another split, a boy) [He] and I was there. He’s more tougher than me so I let him stay. We comfort each other that way. He’s more likeable than me, too. More sincere and happy. He knows none of this matters, it ain’t who we really are.”

So I ask: “What were they testing that way?”

And she answers: “They was gonna see how long we lived I suppose, naked, exposed to rats and such. I don’t know. We ate garbage. I don’t know. They wanted to see what it did to us to be treated like garbage. They asked us lots of questions afterwards, like “who do you want to be now, when you grow up?”

“I want to be a fascist devil like you, sir.” Slap. “I want to be a hooker like your mother, sir.” Slap. It went on and on like that, because, fuck ’em both.”

I think every one of us have a pretty scrappy little rebel in there somewhere, otherwise we probably wouldn’t be here in this room right now. And we can call on that courageous part of us to step up as elders, to hold up a lantern for the next generation. But we need all of us who can do so safely out there doing it. Every disclosure counts. Every time you tell the secret, it’s you one, perps zero. And that’s how we’re going to turn this ship around, one story at a time.

If extreme trauma manifests as catastrophic disconnections, the key to healing is reconnection on every level. And that includes connecting with each other, reconnecting to the society from which we’ve been exiled, and erasing the gigantic disconnect between the underworld we know and the world most people call home. To do this, we need more than leaks, we need a tsunami.

As we move from the Age of Plunder to the Age of Consequences, as peace activist Brian Willson put it, our inside information can help to bridge the dangerous chasm between what the military industrial media complex says is going on, and what the banksters and policy elites are really up to. And that’s because the tyrants at the top of the shadow world’s food chain and the tyrants at the top of the Truman world’s food chain are one and the same. Our truth emergency is everyone’s truth emergency.

Chogyam Trungpa once said “When we talk about compassion, we talk in terms of being kind, but compassion is not so much being kind; it is being creative [enough] to wake a person up.”

The elite ruling class is counting on the great sleeping giant, the people, to stay disconnected, distracted, deceived, and disempowered. Somebody needs to blow the whistle and wake them up.

I humbly invite you to honour the courage, the heart, and the unyielding faith it took for the child in you to deliver you back into an authentic life by sharing your story, your wisdom, and hope for a better, kinder world. We have the power. Together we can help put an end to this insidious reign of terror.

Mahatma Gandhi said, “Whenever I despair, I remember that the way of truth and love has always won. There may be tyrants and murderers, and for a time, they may seem invincible, but in the end, they always fail. Think of it – always.”

May you find peace, and may love always, always abide.

Thank you.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Awful Rowing Speech

S.M.A.R.T. PRESENTATION

Survivors of Extreme Abuse: The Awful Rowing Toward Social Emancipation

August 2010

Hi. My pseudonym is Carmen Holiday, and first of all, I’d like to thank Neil for providing me with this wonderful opportunity to speak, and thanks to all the folks who make this event possible year after year. It’s just an incredible gift, and I’m honored to be here

So I’m Carmen Holiday, also allegedly Cohen, Angleton, Gottlieb, Mengele and many others, meaning that I’m also a product of other minds.

I’m worried I’ll leave out a critical “allegedly” and get someone in trouble, so let me just categorically stamp this entire presentation with a giant “allegedly” stamp, and I’ll do my best along the way. These are strictly my beliefs and opinions unless otherwise noted.

Last fall I wrote a paper about the current social plight of survivors called Survivors of Extreme Abuse: the Awful Rowing Toward Social Emancipation, and I’m going to talk about some of the issues I covered in that paper here today.

When I first realized I was really going to do this thing, I asked a dear friend of mine, who has given a lot more presentations than I have, if she had any ideas for me, any great wisdom to share about the process. And she said, “Well, first and foremost, make sure you’re clear about what you want your take-home message to be, so it won’t get lost in the minutia.”

So I thought about what I could say that might possibly be useful in some way, and I came up with this, as my “take home message,” lest it get lost in the shuffle: It’s true that we survivors have suffered horribly. Many of us have been tortured, both physically and emotionally, in ways most people couldn’t imagine in their worst nightmares. We’ve suffered catastrophic losses. Most of us have lost our families of origin, some of us our own babies and children. And we’ve survived, against terrible odds, only to be disbelieved, ridiculed and ostracized by society at large.

But we’re still standing. And I believe we’re still standing because there was something in us that no one could steal from us: and that’s love. As Anne Sexton wrote, in a letter to her friend Phil Legler: “The sanest thing in this world is love.” And I believe that love is a mighty force to be reckoned with, and that it compels us to share, and I’m going to argue that it can be a powerful, transformative force if it’s shared in the form of telling the truth. And we survivors have some powerful truths to tell.

So, how can truth telling be a transformative force?

On a personal level, telling your story is universally recognized as a crucial component of the healing process, but it’s also important that our stories be heard. Contrary to the old axiom, ignorance is usually not bliss. Except possibly in the short term. Ignorance is helplessness.

The public needs to understand who’s been doing what behind its metaphorical back so that people can protect and empower themselves and their loved ones. A population kept in the dark is a population vulnerable to manipulation and exploitation.

Survivors of extreme abuse have intimate knowledge of unspeakable treachery going on behind closed doors, including the deliberate, trauma-based dissociation of children, child, drug and arms trafficking, child pornography and murder. We can also identify the criminals committing these crimes, some of which are perpetrated by vast organized crime syndicates. In spite of great efforts by those in power in the last few years to normalize torture and state-sanctioned murder, the public would not abide these horrors if they had this information, if they knew what was going on.

I also want to put in a plug for imagination, here, because after enlightenment, transformation requires creative dreamers. Imagine, for example, if all the personal histories in this room were published in one huge volume. Imagine if each one of us had the benefit of knowing what all of us know: All the hard earned wisdom of how to navigate this horrific mess, all the validation – it would be profoundly transformational. And imagine if that book were widely distributed and well read. What if there were a book right next to Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of The United States called A People’s History of Ritual Abuse-Torture and Mind Control?

What if you could walk into your local police station, report ritual abuse crimes, and their first question were “Who’s the leader of the cult?” instead of “Are you on any kind of medication?” What if you could tell your District Attorney that you’d been deliberately dissociated, and that one of your splits had been used to perpetrate a crime, and she said, “Do you have your handler’s contact information?” Instead of “How did you get in here?”

If secret societies, from backwater covens to shadow governments, to transnational corporations, were exposed for what they are, radical reform would be possible, because a citizenry armed with the truth about who’s really doing what can demand accountability. So we’re all stewards of important insights, and what we chose to do, or are able to do with that knowledge does have an impact on other human beings. As Goethe said: “None are so hopelessly enslaved as those who falsely believe they are free.”

People need to wake up to the fact that the human mind is vulnerable to manipulation. The average Joe knows nothing about thought manipulation, let alone deliberate dissociation. We need to wake up Joe.

Cognitive scientist and political analyst George Lakoff wrote a book about the political ramifications of how the mind works called Don’t Think of an Elephant. He talks about why we human folk are susceptible to unconscious manipulation, and why it’s crucial in a democracy that people understand how and why. He writes: “Most of us think we know our own minds. This is because we engage in conscious thought, and it fills much of our waking life. But what most people are not aware of, and are sometimes shocked to discover, is that most of our thought – an estimated 98 percent – is not conscious.” He points out that “Deft politicians (as well as savvy marketers) take advantage of our ignorance of our own minds to appeal to the unconscious level.” 98 percent – that’s a lot of real estate open to exploitation, and some of us have had a whole lot of that space commandeered against our will.

No one wants to believe that they’re not 100 percent in control of their own minds, even though that sense that we are is just a useful illusion.  Part of why our experiences aren’t palatable to Joe is that this is such a threatening idea. No one wants to imagine that it’s possible that they could be manipulated like we were manipulated. There must be something innately wrong with us.

Lakoff writes: “Our knowledge of the mind and the brain has expanded so rapidly over the past three decades that hardly anyone has been able to keep up…this book is devoted to the democratization of knowledge. What is at stake is the deepest form of freedom, the freedom to control our own minds.”

Someone has to step up and tell folks what the shadow class has been up to. We need to help Joe “Lose the official illusions,” to quote Howard Zinn, whom we lost, sadly, this past January.

So what keeps us from speaking out, from outing our perpetrators? Well, lots. First of all, the preconditions for being able to disclose extreme abuse at all are staggering. These include surviving the ordeal in the first place, and surviving with enough of our humanity intact to be able to comprehend and express it. In other words, we have to have been sufficiently resilient and very lucky.

When we’re in a place where we’re able and willing to tell, we face some pretty serious challenges. One fairly persuasive disincentive to telling is having been threatened with death if we dared to, and some of us have witnessed others lose their lives for spilling secrets and exposing criminals. Those of us who were victims of mind control have even more pernicious don’t tell challenges, as many of us were programmed to self-destruct if we dared to speak about our abuse. So telling can be a tricky process before we even set foot out the front door.

When we do go out into the world, with our pain and horror, who do we tell? Coral Theill, author of Bonshea wrote: “A woman’s first scream is for help. Her second scream is for justice.” Well, for ritual abuse and mind control survivors, seeking justice can be another labyrinth of hazards and dilemmas.

For example, secret society superstructures can allegedly make reporting cult crimes problematic. Victims of any organized crime conglomerate run the risk of reporting to someone who’s “connected” – someone who’s part of the network. And, since the truth about our experiences is suppressed and denied culturally, we’re likely to have our disclosures dismissed out of hand regardless of where we turn. Officials who lack specialized training are not likely to have a solid handle on post trauma stress syndromes, or cult psychodynamics or criminal cult social dynamics.

Time is another stinker. It typically takes years of recovery time to get to the point where you’re able to remember and begin to seek justice, so there are statute of limitations issues involved, as well as evidentiary issues, and, of course, officials tend not to see it as a priority as compared to current cases.

Corroboration can also be hard to pin down. It can be difficult to find fellow victims for various reasons, not the least of which is never having known their true name, or not knowing their present name, as many survivors change their names for personal safety reasons. For survivors of organized crime, some witnesses may still be affiliated with the organization, some may be too broken to remember, and some may to be too scared to talk.

In terms of structural challenges, the legal framework generally isn’t in place yet to deal with ritual abuse and torture, but some provisions have been made, in a handful of states, and efforts are underway to address these shortfalls.

In 2008, advocates Linda MacDonald and Jeanne Sarson wrote a report called Torture of Canadian Women by Non-state Actors in the Private Sphere in their effort to make all of Canada a “torture-free-zone.” They point out that since there’s no specific law criminalizing non-state actor torture in Canada, women can’t press criminal charges identifying that they’ve endured torture. They write: “The women frequently experience discreditation, are considered ‘crazy,’ or are labeled mentally ill when seeking professional help.”

Because mind control is impossible, and therefore doesn’t exist, zero provisions have been made, as far as I’m aware, for legal redress. But in terms of medical mind control “experiments,” hope is on the horizon.

Historically, scattered attempts have been made to draw attention to state-sanctioned experiments committed from the ’50’s through the ’70’s, but with limited success. Apart from a few minor exceptions, survivors haven’t been compensated, and investigations and hearings have not resulted in individual perpetrators or institutions being held accountable.

But momentum is growing as more and more survivors of these atrocities come forward, and various related commissions and coalitions are forming to demand acknowledgment and accountability. One such coalition, called the US Truth and Reconciliation Coalition, is currently being launched by Kathleen Sullivan’s North America Freedom Foundation, or NAFF, in an effort to investigate mind control experimentation, torture, enslavement and related human rights violations.

The crime of human trafficking is another common experience among survivors. Some of us have splits who were sold for sex, and some of us have children who were or are being trafficked, a tragedy that gives a whole new meaning to the word “torture.”

The sexual exploitation of women and children is a highly lucrative activity, in part because, as they say, you can sell a weapon or drug once, but you can sell a person hundreds of times. As an estimated 32 billion dollar a year industry, human trafficking is tied for second place with arms smuggling, behind drug trafficking. Yet prior to 2000, no comprehensive Federal law existed to protect victims of trafficking or to prosecute their traffickers. And it wasn’t until two years ago that the US State Department, in their annual reports on the status of human trafficking, acknowledged domestic trafficking at all.

One of the findings was that, contrary to popular perception, the vast majority of sex-trafficked victims in the US are Americans, and predominantly young Americans. That number was estimated as ranging from 100,000 to 300,000, a year, most of them teenage runaways, compared with imported sex workers numbering only between 15,000 and 18,000. And these numbers are based on officially documented cases. So in spite of the fact that the overwhelming majority of sex-trafficked victims are Americans, it wasn’t until 2008 that the State Department acknowledged American born victims at all.

Louise Shelley, founder and director of the Terrorism, Transnational Crime and Corruption Center in Washington, told the conference that: “This is important because we are the only advanced democracy in the world that has the preponderance of its victims be its own citizens and have it be youth. And this is something that we’re not paying enough attention to. We have an enormous problem of victimization in our country, and a vulnerability, and we’re not talking enough about it, and we’re not doing enough about it.”

In February of this year, Ohio’s first ever Trafficking in Persons Study Commission released it’s results. Some of their findings reflect common unjust practices. Matt Leingang, reporting for the AP, wrote: “The report said that besides weak state laws in Ohio, law enforcement agencies often don’t recognize human trafficking when responding to reports of illegal activity. For example, Ohio is quick to label child prostitutes as delinquents and to incarcerate them, rarely looking further at the adults involved.”

Among the observations the subcommittee presented to the commission for consideration was the following: “Those who purchase youth remain protected, receive minimal charges and are rarely prosecuted in a significant way, while traffickers also suffer minimal consequences.”

We’re vilifying at-risk teenagers and protecting rapists and handlers. So we have a long way to go, in terms of social justice.

Where else do survivors turn for help? Many of us choose psychotherapy. Unfortunately, good help is sometimes hard to find. One major obstacle is cost – well-qualified health care professionals are usually very expensive in this country. For many survivors, this fact alone precludes access to professional help. Finding a qualified therapist can also be a big challenge. One reason for this is that the specialty has only relatively recently gained any traction in academia and in the mental health community. Another reason is that mental health care providers often face the same credibility challenges professionally and legally that their patients do socially because of the all-pervasive climate of denial of DID and other dissociative syndromes.

But some brave souls wade right in anyway.

In the April 2010 edition of Lynn Wasnak’s fabulous Many Voices magazine, therapist Cynthia Henrie generously shares her views “from the other side of the couch,” as she puts it. She got her first case of a teenager with DID while working in a residential treatment center, where she’d worked for ten years. She writes:  “When the boy began accepting his multiplicity…and being more open with other clinical personnel, my sanity and credibility were suddenly challenged.”

She notes that before this came up, she’d been credited with being the best therapist they had on staff. She was removed from the case and transferred to a different program. In her words: “They accused me of causing him to become decompensated and fragmented. It was horrible and devastating. The truth is, they pressured me so much that I actually had a break down and had to take a lengthy stress leave to cope with the extreme pressure and demoralization they put me through.”

She also writes: “I am glad it happened though, because it taught me the pressure that clinicians face and why they are taught so little about dissociation in schools and clinical programs. I’ve heard many clinicians, social workers, psychologists and psychiatrists say they don’t believe in DID or have never met a ‘true case.’”

From our side of the couch, talk therapy poses a few thorny challenges as well. First of all, even mental health professionals who specialize in dissociative syndromes struggle with credibility issues, in part because the context of our abuse is so completely hidden from public view. Clouding this issue horribly is the fact that a programmer can allegedly make a split believe she or he is anyone, or anything, or has seen something that is impossible. And some victims of mind control have the added layer of dissociation hell in that we’ve been programmed to switch to splits who will behave in such a way as to destroy our credibility should we begin to remember, and especially if we start to talk about it.

And memory content can include such baffling, inscrutable experiences as forced drug-induced hallucinations, splits speaking in foreign languages, or cult languages, sensory information or narratives from different memories getting lumped together, as sometimes happens (especially when new memories emerge), and the list goes on and on.

And because a survivor may be anywhere on the dissociative continuum when they seek help, or at any point along their healing trajectory, even they may not have enough, if any contextual insight about their experiences to make their case very effectively.

It’s no small wonder, then, that survivors commonly get grossly misunderstood and misdiagnosed. What we say is liable to be read as symbolic at best, or grounds for pharmaceutical interventions or even institutionalization.

Other sticky issues around talk therapy for survivors are to do with equity and trust. The fundamental power imbalance inherent in the way therapists have traditionally been trained to interact with a patient can be counterproductive, because it can feel demeaning and dis-empowering, and we already know all about that stuff.

Along the same lines, the expectation that the therapist should be made aware of intimate details of a patient’s life while they withhold their own histories and honest emotional reactions repeats a familiar dynamic for some survivors. For victims of mind control, it echoes the tyranny of a programmer or handler having intimate knowledge of the many splits they’ve created or have access to, while the victim typically isn’t allowed to know so much as that person’s real name.

Trust is another major challenge in terms of therapeutic relationships for some of us. We typically and understandably emerge from our traumatic experiences with profound trust issues, so that can be a big barrier. So it’s important that clients be treated with respect, and that the therapist’s objective is to empower the client and help them along their particular healing trajectory as a partner, instead of trying to impose their own cure.

Fortunately for us, there are respectful, courageous therapists out there like Henrie, who dare to listen, without judging, and who’ve made great sacrifices, and taken great risks to help us. And we’re honored to have some of them here with us today. I think it’s important to remember that our allies have a choice – they weren’t dragged into this mess kicking and screaming like we were, they could just walk away. But they don’t, they keep fighting the good fight for us and with us.

Survivors in institutional care are especially at risk for mistreatment. Common practices in mental health care facilities can be re-traumatizing, and, for the past few decades, the trend has been toward medicating symptoms and away from exploring root causes. As a backlash to being seen as unscientific and oppressive in the 1970’s, it’s been observed that the discipline of psychiatry shifted radically, beginning in the early 1980’s, to a new paradigm. In their efforts to frame psychiatry as a more legitimate, hard science, there was a move to be theory-neutral by focusing on symptoms only, and dismissing root causes.

In what other scientific discipline is it acceptable to ignore causation?

In my humble opinion, a psychiatric oligarchy that’s pre-occupied with proving it’s not a soft science is doing us no favors. Some of us have had our fill of hard science, having allegedly been frozen, drugged, electro-shocked, starved and implanted with hardware by men and women in white coats. I believe soft, warm and fuzzy science is in order.

Another commonly cited influence for the shift in focus toward symptomatology and away from causation is this: Whereas treating someone with a history of extreme trauma is a complicated, time consuming, delicate task, a disembodied bundle of symptoms can be treated with drugs. And that’s very good for Big Pharma’s bottom line, but very bad for survivors of extreme trauma.

A study published in 2006 called Financial Ties Between DSM-IV Panel Members and the Pharmaceutical Industry found that 100 percent of the members who contributed to the diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia/psychotic disorders had financial ties to the pharmaceutical industry. 100 percent – every last one of them. So Big Pharma gets to use the DSM to sell its products, and survivors of extreme abuse get reduced to a checklist of symptoms.

Another potential barrier to trusting mental health professionals for a mind control survivor is having been victimized by them as a child, and this brings us to the true history of psychiatry in this country. Some of us were an integral, involuntary part of that history as children.

Many of the psychiatrists and other scientists and academicians who were involved in mind control activities post WWII were not rank outsiders, but mainstream professionals. As Dr. Colin Ross, author of The CIA Doctors, was quoted as saying at a conference in 1996, “Virtually every leading psychiatrist in North America between the 1940’s and the 1970’s was involved in some aspect of the CIA’s mind control research.”

He also said: “The history of psychiatry in the second half of the twentieth century has undoubtedly been strongly skewed – not by an agenda that has to do with academic research, not by the best interest of clients, not by ethical psychiatry – but by an Intelligence agenda.”

In John Marks’ book The Search for the Manchurian Candidate, he describes Dr. Harold Wolff, and his relationship with the CIA. Wolff was a world famous neurologist, and, in 1960, President of the American Neurological Association. These accounts elucidate, in Wolff’s own hair-raising words, what that Intelligence agenda really was: “Once he figured out how the human mind really worked, Wolff wrote, he would tell the Agency ‘how a man can be made to think, feel, and behave according to the wishes of other men.’”

In order to aid him in his efforts to understand men’s minds, he asked the Agency to give him access to everything in its files on “threats, coercion, imprisonment, isolation, deprivation, humiliation, torture, ‘brainwashing,’ ‘black psychiatry,’ hypnosis, and combinations of these with or without chemical agents.” Pretty nasty shopping list.

Wolff created an organization called the Society for Human Ecology, to study how to best “indoctrinate and motivate” people, by focusing on man in relationship to his total environment. In 1957, Wolff invited onetime Assistant Secretary of State Adolf Berle to join the board. Marks writes that: “…he came on the Society board despite some reservations. “I am frightened about this one,” Berle wrote in his diary. “If the scientists do what they have laid out for themselves, men will become manageable ants.”

So it was all about control, every tyrant’s fondest dream.

Marks’ work was based on documents he obtained through the Freedom of Information Act, and from interviews with many of the key players. Well, the official history of the federal agencies that conducted mind control experiments is riddled with critical and, in my opinion, criminal omissions. To state the obvious, our stories, the perspectives of the unwitting and unwilling subjects, are almost categorically left out. Official documents and interviews with the perpetrators involved predictably give a very distorted view of the facts.

Contrary to the official story, the CIA and other government agencies did successfully hone the art of mind control, (an art that other cults and cultures have exploited throughout the ages) to a truly awe-inspiring level of sophistication. By throwing lots of money and research and profoundly disturbed doctors at the problem, they expanded on the research done in German prison camps and got their wish: traumatized, toy people.

Official documents invariably state that it was all for naught, that mind control was never achieved. Well, that’s BIG FAT LIE number one. In my opinion.

Also contrary to the official story, it wasn’t just “men” who were being manipulated and experimented on. In my alleged experience it was almost exclusively children who were being tortured and programmed. In her Report to the Presidential Committee on Radiation and Mind Control in 1995, the intrepid Claudia Mullens wrote, of the subjects chosen for the experiments, “Most were females between the age of five and early thirties.”

A third gaping lapse in sincerity, in official documents and publications based on them, is that they talk about “experimenting,” “de-patterning,” “psychic driving,” electro-shocking, drugging and hypnotizing, when what they were actually doing was torturing people, full stop. But since no doctor was going to risk his sterling obituary in the New York Times, (or being tarred and feathered in the streets) they used euphemisms and sometimes very elaborate but vague obfuscation to describe their work, further dishonoring their victims.

And in my experience, only some of what was done was experimental in nature – much of it was just standard procedure. To put so much emphasis on experiments obscures the fact that they were successful, and that methods were standardized and implemented as a matter of course. Allegedly.

So what did they do with their new toy-people? Well, they said they were only after the Russians, but as it happens, certain factions allegedly made lots of money and blackmailed lots of politicians by sexually exploiting our splits in every conceivable manner. They allegedly trained some of them up for combat, and others were trained as couriers, smugglers, spies and assassins, among other horrors.

So it’s easy to see why secrecy and damage control are something of a concern to these folks, and it’s easy to imagine why some of us look upon the world of psychiatric “care” with a little skepticism. It might be equally obvious who benefits from keeping the basic facts about a natural mechanism like dissociation from the public purview: the shadow elite who exploit it. The way I see it.

There are several books out, now, about the CIA and mind control, and even ritual abuse, but there’s also a whole lot of disinformation and censorship going on. Also, books about our stories tend to be issue silos, intentionally or unintentionally omitting important contextual information, like blind hands feeling only part of the elephant. We need to back up and see the entire creature.

For example, child sex-trafficking and child pornography are rarely mentioned in the context of ritual abuse and mind control, which, to me, is like writing a book about Vegas but leaving out the casinos. Also usually omitted is the fact that many ritual abuse practices are means to an end, mind control, and that mind control isn’t just about turning children into sex toys or lethal weapons, or the subsequent commodification of these children, but is, in my view, part of the much wider objective of general social control.

Russ Baker, award-winning journalist and author, wrote a fascinating, 592 page book called Family of Secrets: The Bush Dynasty, America’s Invisible Government, and the Hidden History of the Last Fifty Years, the result of exhaustive research. In his words, “The more I learned, the broader my questions grew. And as my research deepened, disturbing patterns coalesced.”

He writes about what he describes as: “The cozy relationships between titans of industry, finance, media, government, military, and intelligence – and the revolving door between those sectors.” And he goes on to expose this incredible interconnectedness amongst what emerges as a relatively small group of elites whose families have been major players for generations, in some cases back to the founding of the country.

He notes in several places that a number of these men have Masonic affiliations. He writes: “One does not need to put too fine a point on this to recognize that such bonds of loyalty and discretion…do wonders for preserving secrecy over long periods of time, and are therefore enormously useful for maintaining discipline within vast covert operations networks.”

As a depressingly vivid example of these disturbing, cozy relationships, Baker writes the following about the lack of firewalls between media and power brokers:

Bush got money from Uncle Herbie (George   Herbert Walker  Jr., Skull and Bones, 1927), an investment banker. Uncle Herbie also was instrumental in bringing in others, including Eugene Meyer, a Yale graduate and owner of the influential Washington Post. Meyer’s investments were handled by Brown Brothers Harriman.

Meyer was one of many media titans, such as Prescott Bush’s good friend and fellow Bonesman Henry Luce, founder of Time magazine, and William Paley of CBS (on whose board Prescott sat), who shared an interest in intelligence. In a 1977 Rolling Stone article, Carl Bernstein, famed for breaking the Watergate story in the Washington Post, states that both Luce and Paley cooperated regularly with the CIA, and even mentions his own paper’s history with the agency.

In the book Secrets: The CIA’s War at Home, written by Angus MacKenzie, he wrote: “Only recently in the history of the world’s oldest republic has secrecy functioned principally to keep the American people in the dark about the nefarious activities of their government.”

Well, just last month, journalists Bill Arkin and Dana Priest wrote a firestorm of a series of articles published in the Washington Post called Top Secret America, which exposes the massive outsourcing of US Intelligence since 9-11. The series of articles begins: “The top-secret world the government created in response to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, has become so large, so unwieldy and so secretive that no one knows how much money it costs, how many people it employs, how many programs exist within it or exactly how many agencies do the same work.”

Among the findings: An estimated 854,000 people hold top-secret security clearances. More than 1,200 government organizations and nearly 2,000 private companies work on programs related to counterterrorism, homeland security and intelligence in 10,000 locations.

In an interview with Amy Goodman of Democracy Now, Bill Arkin described how he and Priest realized that “Something had been created since 9/11 that wasn’t normal, that wasn’t on the books, that looked like it was a gigantic superstructure on top of regular government.”

Adding insult to injury, according to several news agencies, Google recently teamed up with the CIA to fund a startup called Recorded Future, that monitors thousands of websites, blogs and Twitter accounts, looking for patterns and relationships.

So, clearly we’re not moving in the direction of transparency and freedom, but toward ever-increasing secrecy and oppression.

So, how can we prevail over such powerful forces? Well, in the case of secret criminal organizations, the key to their power, apart from ruthlessness, is secrecy. And that’s the good news, because secrecy isn’t like extreme wealth, lethal technology, vast networking, or other crucial staples of their success. Secrecy can be annihilated with words. And that’s why they have to work so hard, in so many arenas, to shut us up. If their power lies in secrecy and ruthlessness, ours lies in truth-telling and loving kindness.

As Emma Goldman wrote: “The most violent element of society is ignorance.” So we need to democratize our knowledge. Joe needs to know what we know.

We need to help right this topsy-turvy world where sexually exploited teenagers get incarcerated but their rapists and handlers go free, where doctors who perform monstrous acts on defenseless children are widely revered, and their victims are labeled “crazy.” The sanest thing is love.

These criminals who’ve been tragically divorced from their own humanity are not invincible. They can destroy thousands of documents, but they can’t destroy the truth. They can’t gag the countless witnesses to their repugnant crimes. And in spite of all of the monumental barriers to speaking out that I’ve laid out here, many survivors and allies have stepped up and risked much to tell the truth.

Howard Zinn reminded us repeatedly that change happens from the bottom up. He said, “It will look small and pitiful, but that’s how movements start.”

If it’s too dangerous or difficult for you to speak out, there’s still a lot you can do. Foster solidarity. Don’t be afraid to ask for help when you’re on your knees, and when you get back up again, help someone else up off the floor. Support an advocacy organization, or truth-seeking coalition. You can fill out questionnaires, and participate in surveys. You don’t have to reinvent the wheel, we survivors and our allies are doing amazing, courageous things.

Because in spite of everything our perpetrators robbed from us, and all the obstacles we face, we’re not doomed to stand idly by, in silence, while they exploit another generation of innocent children. And if our suffering isn’t publicly acknowledged in our lifetimes, if we don’t live to see our truths exposed, then let our shoulders be the ones the next generation can stand on.

In the words of Arthur Schopenhauer: “All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed, second it is violently opposed, and third, it is accepted as self-evident.”

We made it here today because, although we may be battle-scarred, we’re not broken. We may have wanted to give up a thousand times, we may have tried to give up a thousand times, but here we are. We hope for something better. They couldn’t extinguish our hope. Or courage. If there’s one thing present in spades in this room, it’s courage.

When you were young, you had the courage to fight for your life and your sanity, year after year, armed only with the coping skills of a terrified child. You may have kept up the battle carrying the heavy, awful burden of having watched others die in your wake. But you’re still standing.

As an adult, you’ve had the courage to remember, when so many others haven’t. You have the courage, every time a new memory bomb is dropped on your life, to get back up, shake off the dust and carry on, with yet another horrible truth you have to find some way to come to terms with. You have the courage, every single day, to walk this world under the weight of terrible secrets, terrible knowledge, in a culture that almost categorically denies your reality.

But together we will prevail. Love will prevail.

So I encourage you to tell your story, if it’s safe to tell, to help expand our humble little mosaic of voices so people can begin to understand that things are not always what they seem, that people are not always what they seem. And so that we can re-ignite the hope that has been denied to so many, for that child who is inevitably going to come to harm tonight, in some lonely, secret space, but will pray for mercy and dream of love.

Thank you.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on The Awful Rowing Speech